MNS and the "outsiders"


On Sunday, violence erupted in Mumbai (not again…). Taxi-drivers, paan-wallas and ‘outsiders’ (read UPites and Biharis) were the target of assault by frenzied MNS supporters. In an is-it-related-or-not incident, Amitabh Bachchan’s house was attacked the next day, spurred by resentment towards his move to set up a girls’ school in Uttar Pradesh rather than Maharashtra.

I was at home on Horror Monday (Can we call it that? – We’d probably have to name at least one day each month for the sundry episodes of communal clashes that errupt so frequently in this so-called cosmopolitan metropolis). The news channels had a field day running and re-running the clips of a taxi-driver being dragged out of his car and beaten to pulp and soundbytes with the public expressing their outrage at this breach of peace.

Yesterday a reader wrote to me saying that he’d dropped into my blog for news on this event and was disappointed to hear me talking about art and festivals instead. Point taken. I’m part of that unconcerned, educated upper-middle class elite that tut-tuts about the ruin our politicians are bringing to the country and then does nothing about it.

To be quite honest, I don’t know what to say. On one hand, we’ve gotten practically used to cricket pitches being dug up, shops shut down, bandhs called, trains delayed, people being beaten up by the saffron brigade. And then there’s the reality that the news channels rarely, if ever, cover the truth as is.

As a point of fact, I travelled across the city yesterday and today. For all purposes Mumbai is its usual bustling, thriving self. It’s like it might not have been at all.

And then I wonder, how does the driver of the taxi I’m in, feel? Is he really waiting for the signal to change or is he actually casting a wary eye around at would-be attackers? How about the doodhwala by whose doorbell ring we can set our alarm clocks? To be here at 5:30 a.m. I only wonder what time he’d have to get up. The much-maligned autorickshaw-wallas?

At the end of all that, I wonder, does it matter? Does the MNS or Shiv Sena before them really believe that they can ‘rid’ Mumbai of its outsiders? More likely, no one’s thinking or caring about that far into the future. It’s the here and now. Any publicity is good publicity, be it ever so blood-spattered.

And guess what – it’s the lower extremes that get the cut, like extensions getting pruned away. Who cares, they’ll grow back tomorrow! So while AB gets his security beefed up, our roads are awash with lingering fear writ large on the faces of nameless people who make this city run.

I’m just wondering if the welfare of Maharashtrians is the cause, is anyone thinking of what’s happening within the state? But I suppose dying farmers aren’t as catchy a story. So much easier to just grab a punching bag.

In a related aside, do read this post and the comments that follow. The image I’m carrying in my mind is of a fat goose that lays golden eggs. Everyone’s trying to get a piece of it and brush off everyone else’s hands..and so what if the goose is strangulated in the process?? That’s Mumbai.

Tagged: , , , , , ,

8 thoughts on “MNS and the "outsiders"

  1. dusty February 6, 2008 at 12:59 Reply

    Hey long time since I have been here. Just a thought,but isn’t it time that the people of mumbai stopped taking so much pride in, “Mumbai will still go on” “Nothing fazes Mumbai” “A city that never cripples” etc sentiment, and actually make that a “weakness” of the city? Maybe then we will see reactions emanating from the public that could rid the city of such perils, than allow a tiny section of society from targetting “outsiders” so to speak. These very “outsiders” or “extensions” like you mention, along with the locals make Mumbai what it is. Perhaps the fact that Mumbai continues to go on, no matter what, encourages unsavoury elements to do what they do?
    I could be completely wrong, but this thought came to mind when i read your post.
    Have a nice day.

    Like

  2. IdeaSmith February 6, 2008 at 13:34 Reply

    @ dusty: I was thinking about that too. I actually thought of ending the post with “So much for the chalta hai attitude.” but I didn’t. I often think it isn’t pride that makes Mumbaikers say ‘The city goes on’…it’s sheer resignation.

    Like

  3. Dopedup February 6, 2008 at 19:45 Reply

    This just creates a rift between the people , there are dozens of starvations deaths and farmer sucides each week , going unreported in the news , ignored by the politicians. The sena rose up in popularity due to their agenda against the south indians and the mns is now up against the up / bihar people.

    a big F U C K – Y O U to all indian politicians

    Like

  4. Sumit February 7, 2008 at 08:26 Reply

    The point about any publicity being good is the vital component. All news channels carried more or less the same footage. It was not a news agency feed (you can see glimpses of different cameramen). The people indulging in the mindless violence did not mind it a bit when the cameramen more or less stuck the camera in their face. All news channels had their people live on the scene.

    This was premeditated. The media was informed well in advance. This is MNS’ idea of a press conference.

    Like

  5. IdeaSmith February 8, 2008 at 08:04 Reply

    @ Dopedup: It seems like a stunt (see Sumit’s comment after yours). And an FO hardly suffices…more and more I wonder what we are doing about it. Hmm?

    @ Sumit: Valid point.

    Like

  6. fullmoononearth February 8, 2008 at 13:03 Reply

    The incident left me with a thought, “No wonder we were ruled for 200 years.”

    Like

  7. IdeaSmith February 14, 2008 at 09:14 Reply

    @ fullmoononearth: And I second that.

    Like

  8. Which Main? What Cross? February 14, 2008 at 10:54 Reply

    I was in Mumbai on Monday and everything seemed normal!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: